https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2023/08/is-art-generated-by-artificial-intelligence-real-art/
This article dives into the relationship between AI and various different art practices. It raises questions about AI’s ability to create art in general, its impact on the traditional practices of art, and its role as either a threat or a tool within the industry. The Article first addresses the difference between human written stories and AI stories in order to reveal AI’s inability to accomplish the same level of creativity and originality compared to a real human mind. Human stories often include unique perspectives, language, and experiences in general that AI generated content usually lacks. I think that uniqueness is essential in creating creative work such as artistic projects. Since AI focuses on replication and already existing facts and stories, it would be hard, in my opinion, for AI to create good art without the aid of humans. The article also talks about AI in the music industry. In the realm of music, the discussion about AI’s involvement shifts towards the performative aspect of art. In this article the consensus seems to be that AI falls short of capturing the emotional and spontaneous aspects that define live musical performances. While AI can compose music, it often lacks the emotion and dramatism that human composers often base their works off of. Without this level of emotional intelligence that humans have but AI lacks, the music AI creates will lack any sort of relatability that isn't just surface level. This article does however acknowledge AI’s potential as a tool or collaborator in the artistic world. For instance, in animation there is a recognition that AI can be trained to mimic a particular style or assist in certain tasks in the animation process. Although it is not able to fully replace the human touch and intentionality that artists bring to the table, it can be used to aid artists in their work and make their process easier. The perspective of viewing AI as a collaborator rather than a threat to the artistic world is one that I think is very refreshing and worth diving into. This view acknowledges the inevitable advancement of technology and emphasizes its ability to work with humans while still valuing the creativity and unique ideas of humans on their own. I think this creates a dialogue between artists and AI that can be used to their advantage rather than creating a stigma around AI that coins it as a competitor. I think there is a balance between AI and artists that can be reached and harnessed in order to help humans reach their full potential as artists no matter what the industry is. Overall, the article prompts reflection within readers on the evolving relationship between AI and art, highlighting both the potential limitations of AI while also emphasizing its potential as a tool. It underscores the need for artists to adapt with the times and be innovative in the way they utilize technology as it advances to explore new possibilities while still staying true to the essence of human expression and imagination.
Comentarios